Why Priests Can Misbehave With Impunity

Catherine Deveney, in the Guardian, neatly identifies two key factors that explain how the Catholic sex-abuse scandals could become so widespread, endemic, and lasting:

The first is “scandalising the faithful”. Traditionally, the hierarchy believed the greatest sin was shaking the faith of Catholic congregations. Protecting them meant concealing scandal. Adopting that as your moral standpoint means anything goes. You can cover up sexual misconduct from those you demand sexual morality from. You can conceal financial corruption from those who put their pounds in the collection plate. You can silence the abused and protect the abuser. Guilt about sacrificing individuals is soothed by protecting something bigger and more significant – the institution.

The second concept is “clericalism”, a word used to describe priests’ sense of entitlement, their demand for deference and their apparent conformity to rules and regulations in public, while privately behaving in a way that suggests the rules don’t apply to them personally. (O’Brien was, in that sense, a classic example.) The Vatican is an independent state; the Holy See a sovereign entity recognised in international law and governed by the Pope. The Nunciature operates like government embassies in different countries worldwide. It is even governed by its own rules: Canon Law. All this contributes to the notion that the church can conduct its own affairs without interference or outside scrutiny. It demands a voice in society without being fully accountable to it.

One-Third of Americans Want Theocracy

One third of all Americans would support scrapping or revising the First Amendment to make way for an official state religion. Only one half are opposed.

abuso

Although the North Carolina House of Representatives killed a bill Thursday that would have paved the way for establishing an official state religion, a new national HuffPost/YouGov poll finds widespread support for doing so.

The new survey finds that 34 percent of adults would favor establishing Christianity as the official state religion in their own state, while 47 percent would oppose doing so. Thirty-two percent said that they would favor a constitutional amendment making Christianity the official religion of the United States, with 52 percent saying they were opposed.

[image via verdadyluzhoy]

After a Cross/Swastika Doodle, Five Are Dead

Deadly doodle:

Five Egyptians were killed and eight wounded in clashes between Christians and Muslims in a town near Cairo, security sources said on Saturday, in the latest sectarian violence in the most populous Arab state. … Four Christian Copts and one Muslim were killed when members of both communities started fighting and shooting at each other.

news_165327_0

Residents said the violence broke out on Friday when a group of Christian children were drawing on a wall of a Muslim religious institute. A Reuters reporter saw what looked like a swastika drawn on the wall, which Muslim residents said had offended them because it looked like a cross.

[image via star africa]

Huge Bangladeshi Crowd Chants ‘Kill Atheists’

Vast throngs of people marched on the Bangladeshi capital today to demand the execution of four atheists. The protest comes five weeks after a local atheist blogger was murdered by Muslim assassins.

Dhaka march Islam bloggers - Google Search

Hundreds of thousands of Islamists rallied in Dhaka on Saturday after staging a “long march” to the Bangladeshi capital to demand the execution of atheist bloggers for allegedly defaming Islam. It was the latest protest to rack Bangladesh, deepening tensions between secularists and the largest Islamic party, Jamaat-e-Islami, whose leaders are under trial for crimes committed during the country’s 1971 war of independence.

The Islamists converged on Dhaka’s main commercial hub to protest against what they said were blasphemous writings by atheist bloggers, shouting “God is great — hang the atheist bloggers”.

Footage of the protest here.

[image via Financial Express]

Breaking: Pastor Rick Warren’s Son Just Committed Suicide

“In spite of America’s best doctors, meds, counselors, and prayers for healing, the torture of mental illness never subsided,” mega-church pastor Rick Warren wrote today, after his 27-year-old son Matthew took his own life.

Our thoughts and wishes of strength go to all of Matthew’s loved ones, especially his family.

Catholics Redefine ‘Zero Tolerance’

Eleven years ago, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops adopted “zero tolerance” guidelines for dealing with sexually abusive clergy members. The guidelines were issued to help restore faith in the Church’s tattered image.

Many priests and their protectors and enablers seem not to have gotten the memo. The Chicago Tribune examines a few local cases of priests who, despite a record of inappropriate touching and worse, never came close to being disciplined, much less terminated, much less turned over to the police. Here is the opening section of the article:

When Will County sheriff’s deputies found the Rev. William Virtue sneaking into a private quarry in 1986, police records state that the Roman Catholic priest had blankets, two six packs of beer and a 10-year-old boy with him. He fled on foot when officers arrived, leaving the child behind.

Dammit, why couldn’t the Rev. Virtue’s first name have been Richard? Dick Virtue would have been perfect.

Authorities took Virtue into custody after he returned to his car but later released him without charges because the boy’s mother said she had given her son permission to go swimming with the priest. Still, a deputy forwarded the report to Joliet Diocese officials who put it into Virtue’s personnel file — which already contained several accusations involving inappropriate behavior with underage boys.

catholic church sexual abuse scandal women's ordination priesthood hypocrisy confession cartoon by mike peters dayton daily news

The arrest report would remain tucked away for 20 years as Virtue continued to have contact with youths, and even after a seemingly repentant Joliet Diocese pledged in 2002 to improve its handling of sex abuse cases and held up guidelines approved by American bishops as proof of its commitment to transparency and victims’ needs.

Virtue’s personnel file, which contains 500 pages of letters, memos and reports, reflects the struggles the church faced since its public vow to better protect children after a bruising, national sex abuse scandal. Records obtained by the Tribune reveal several instances in which the diocese’s handling of abuse allegations contradicted those promises, adding to concerns about the overall efficacy of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People that U.S. bishops signed amid fanfare.

There can be little doubt that this story has repeated itself, and is repeating itself today, all over the Catholic world. See also here, and here, and here.

The wonderful part for the abusers is not only that they keep their jobs and keep getting paid (essentially by the very parishioners whose children they assault with their saintly cocks). It is not even that they keep getting access to molestable boys and girls, though I’m sure the padres appreciate that very much. No: the sweetest advantage of being a Christian abuser is that you get to enjoy the fruits of your redemptive faith, which holds that you will sit at the feet of the Heavenly Father for eternity if only you mutter a few apologetic prayers about your child-fucking ways.

Say “Forgive me Father, for I have sinned”… and before too long, your slate is wiped clean.

The Catholic doctrine of forgiveness, as warm and fuzzy as that word sounds, is the very article of faith that makes unending child abuse possible. If there’s no misdeed that can’t be erased by prayerfully showing penitence to Jesus, who already blotted away your sins by dying for them, then no heavenly consequences will likely ensue. Real contrition and self-improvement are, evidently, for suckers.

[cartoon via Wisdom Quarterly]

Bombs for Allah

Another atrocity by a no doubt highly religious Muslim:

A suicide bomber blew himself up Saturday at a lunch hosted by a Sunni candidate in Iraq’s upcoming regional elections, killing 20 people, officials said. The blast ripped through a hospitality tent pitched next to the house of Muthana al-Jourani, who is running for the provincial council and held the lunch rally for supporters, councilman Sadiq al-Huseini said.

Expect more of this in the next few weeks:

Violence is expected to surge in the run up to Iraq’s provincial elections on April 20.

Amish Beardicide Perps Fight For Their Freedom

The infamous Mullet clan is unhappy with its incarceration:

Attorneys for a group of Amish men and women found guilty of hate crimes for cutting the hair and beards of fellow members of their faith are arguing that the group’s conviction, sentencing and imprisonment in separate facilities across the country violates their constitutional rights and amounts to cruel and unusual punishment, according to recent court filings.

The filings in federal court in Akron seek the release of seven of 16 Amish convicted in September in the 2011 eastern Ohio attacks, which were meant to shame fellow Amish they believed were straying from strict religious interpretations.

I confess I’m mostly highlighting this story because it gives me a chance to share the priceless police mug shots of the Amish gang members who committed beardicide most foul:

30-naughty-amish

Do you have a favorite? Mine is the guy in the top right corner. He reminds me of the character on Gentle Giant’s first album cover. The likeness would be almost perfect if only he’d turn his frown upside down. C’mon, why so glum, chum?

Photoshop-2On with the article:

The Amish have been sent to different prisons across the country, placing an overly harsh burden on their relatives, who, because of their religion, cannot travel by plane and have to hire drivers for car travel, the group’s attorneys argue.

Correction: it’s not that they “cannot travel by plane.” It is that for reasons that are entirely their own, they choose not to. I’m sympathetic to Mrs. Mullet, who, in order to visit her husband and sons, has to travel to Oklahoma, Louisiana, and to two prisons in Minnesota that are 160 miles apart. That prison authorities separated her family members, and sent them to be incarcerated in far-flung places, does add to her burden, and I wish that the Bureau of Prisons had made less onerous accommodations. (I also happen to think the “hate crime” convictions and their associated prison terms were, in this case, well outside the bounds of fairness).

Still: that Mrs. Mullet finds herself encumbered by the travel requirement has less do with the United States government, and more with the fact that the Mullets and their brethren think it’s spiritually icky to drive a car or clamber aboard a big metal bird.

Prosecutors, in their response filed on Friday, pointed out that Mullet has unsuccessfully argued to be released five times throughout the case, and they cited comments from federal Judge Dan Polster that Mullet showed no remorse for the attacks and “enjoyed receiving prompt reports about the violent assaults, and even received a bag of hair as proof that one such assault was successful.”

The arrest and trial of the Mullet clan was far and away the best religion story of the last couple of years. I mean no disrespect to the victims, who suffered the terrible trauma of a free trim, but the real reason I’m sorry the attacks occurred is because a crime of faith so Pythonesque and preposterous won’t soon be equaled, let alone topped.

Canadian Slackers Take Shortcut to Paradise

Muslims believe that ascending to paradise requires the usual avoidance of temptations: no alcohol, no drugs, no sleeping around, etc. But why adhere to such sacrificial purity if you can simply become a martyr with almost no effort? Why not just kill a bunch of infidels and go straight to your heavenly reward?

There’s a perverse logic to that, especially if you’re young and aimless and you can’t hold down a job because the boss won’t repeatedly give you time to pray during work hours. You’d have to be a fool to take the 100-mile path if there’s a 100-yard shortcut at hand. Oh, and you can stick it to the establishment while you’re at it.

And so…

MONTREAL — Shocked to learn that two of their own attacked a desert gas plant in Algeria, Canadians are struggling to understand how young men from a quiet, middle-class neighborhood ended up as jihadists.

It was announced by Algerian officials almost immediately after the days-long siege of the In Amenas plant by the Algerian army in January that the pair were among the dead. One intelligence source said they were Arabs with dual citizenship and were among the 29 Islamists killed in the bloodbath, alongside 38 hostages. But it was only this week [that] Canadian media revealed that they were actually former schoolmates who grew up in sleepy London, Ontario.

The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation named the jihadis-next-door as

Xristos Katsiroubas, 22 from a Greek Orthodox family

(in Greek, Xristos mean Christ, no less!),

and Ali Medlej, 24. They died during the siege, possibly by blowing themselves up. Both apparently had become angry and alienated at home, and eventually ruptured ties with their families, reports said. After high school, they also reportedly struggled to keep menial jobs as employers refused to allow them time to pray.

A former friend told the CBC that Medlej had once told him he did not want to give up women and drinking. “There’re things that I just can’t give up in my lifestyle, and it’s hard for me to be a practicing Muslim, so why don’t I just be a shaheed (martyr) and go straight to heaven instead of all the effort that I can’t seem to do,” Medlej was quoted as saying by his former friend.

Americans Own Half a Billion Bibles; Love to Say They Adore the Book, Let It Gather Dust

More than half of Americans think the Bible doesn’t have enough influence on a culture that they see as being in moral decline, a new survey says.

But of course what they mean is that they read and follow the Bible faithfully; it’s those other Christians (not to mention the heathens) who, being insufficiently pious, are helping tilt the country towards Sodom and Gomorrah.

read_me_bible

Eighty-eight percent of respondents said they own a Bible, and the average household has 4.4 Bibles. With about 115 million U.S. households, that means we collectively own more than a half billion Bibles.

Not sure the holiness is rubbing off.

How many of those books are just sitting around for show, gathering dust? Here’s an indication: Only one in five respondents say they read the Bible on a regular basis. The majority (57 percent) read the Good Book four times a year or fewer — which probably means they’re going to hell.

The young ‘uns are even less inclined to curl up with the written word of God. Almost six in ten Americans between ages 18 and 28 read the Bible fewer than three times a year, if at all.

Note: The number of self-professed Bible readers is probably inflated, due to Social Desirability Bias.

[image via EthiOrthodox Youth]

Men Behaving Badly — Special Priest Edition

Clergy crime roundup. All stories from April 5 (today) only.

• A former dean of a Roman Catholic cathedral in the UK has been charged by the police with three counts of indecent assault against an individual. [link]

• A retired Church of England priest and a former organist and choirmaster have been found guilty of a string of child sex abuse offenses dating back more than 25 years. Prosecutors said the priest used the respectability of the cassock to groom and abuse two boys over an 18-month period from when they were aged around 13. [link]

catholic-church-sexual-abuse-rape-children-scandal-pedophile-priest-bishops-cover-up-hypocrisy-cartoon-by-chris-britt-state-journal-register-springfield-IL

• A former Roman Catholic priest convicted of raping two altar boys in the 1980s has been denied a new trial by the Massachusetts Appeals Court. The priest was convicted in February 2011 of rape of a child by force and indecent assault and battery on a child under age 14, and sentenced to up to 25 years in prison. He claims he didn’t get a fair trial. [link]

• A suspended California priest charged with seven felony counts of child molestation was brought into court today, in preparation for the trial against him that will start on Tuesday. He is accused of seven counts of lewd and lascivious acts with a teenage girl during a two-year span, starting when she was 14. [link]

•  A New York priest who’d already been charged with five counts of child rape was arraigned Friday in Salem, Mass., Superior Court, on an additional count. The new indictment alleges that, in the early eighties, he raped a seven-year-old child. [link]

• A new Michigan lawsuit against a priest and the Catholic church says they failed to protect a 14-year-old girl from sexual abuse by a 19-year-old man. The suit says the priest and church were negligent and failed to act after getting reports of the sexual misconduct. [link]

• Australia’s long-awaited clergy-child-abuse investigation kicked off this week. The Winnipeg Free Press says the years-long probe looks set to dwarf even the Irish investigation by the Ryan Commission, which revealed that police had colluded with the Catholic Church in covering up clerical child abuse in Dublin and beyond. At least 5,000 people are expected to give evidence during the Australian inquiry, compared with just 1,500 in the Irish one. [link]

 [cartoon via Transmission Media]

Children’s Pastor Is Secretly a Child-Porn Fiend

KRQE.com reports that

A children’s pastor at an Albuquerque [NM] church is facing federal charges of receiving and possessing child pornography.

Pastor Derek Schwartzrock, 34, was arrested Wednesday by agents from Homeland Security Investigations and the New Mexico State Police, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office. He is expected to make his initial appearance in court on Friday.

The agents, acting with a search warrant, seized a computer and related media from Schwartzrock’s home and later reported [they found] 12,000 images that appeared to be “consistent with child pornography.”

Schwartzrock may be facing more charges than just those related to possession of child pornography. Police say he failed a polygraph test when he was asked if he had ever touched a child inappropriately.